Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Fear this

How's this for something to fear? God says he will harden Pharoah's heart so that He can punish him so that the Israelites can see the power of God.

This is something that from time to time in my life has caused me a great deal of anguish. Here's why: It shows the sovereignty of God. He is omnipotent and he uses that power to accomplish his purpose. I have or at least feel like I have very little to say about that purpose. Take the case of Pharoah. He ran up against the will of God in the worst way and paid for it with everything he held dear and still didn't have the chance to follow God at the end. His problem wasn't in what he did, it was in who he did it to. Hundreds of Pharoahs acted in a similar manner and didn't receive any temporal punishment. Instead they got to live a life of luxury and build impressive monuments to themselves on the backs of other groups of people who weren't the chosen of God.

This Pharoah ran up against God's chosen people at the particular time God had chosen to call them and give them a sign of his faithfulness. So the question that inevitably rises in my mind is why this Pharoah at this particular time. The same question arises--why Jacob and not Esau? or why Abraham and not some other nomad wandering out in the desert? or why Isaac and not Ishmael? None of these questions seems to have an answer that can be answered by human understanding. Why are some called by God and some not? According to this passage and others--because they fit his purpose.

This is not a critique of God--just an openly asked question. Why are some chosen for punishment? and if Pharoah, why not me?

Monday, January 29, 2007

A Review: Babel

What do an ageing illegal immigrant in the US, a couple vacationing in Morroco whose marriage is on the rocks, a teenage shepard in the morroccan desert and a deaf Japanese girl stuggling with daddy issues have in common? Not much apparantly.

That's about it for the movie.

On to the movie theatre. Why do we continue to patronize them?

Here's my summary of a trip to the theater. First, it has an 18 dollar entrance fee for a couple makes it just about the most expensive date possible, even with a relatively inexpensive meal beforehand. Then you are crammed into room with hundreds of strangers. Airplanes excepted it is probably the most crowded place you are likely to experience in contemporary American life. Even with stadium seating and the bigger modern seats you cannot escape the stifling crowdedness of the place. As you walk in the popcorn crunches and the soda sticks underfoot.

Then you're stuck. The seat even if comparably comfortable quickly annoys. It doesn't recline and there's nowhere to put your feet. You can barely change position without disturbing someone--not that there is any reasonable way to change position. And you can forget about going to the bathroom. Not only will you upset everyone between you and the aisle, but you can bet that they'd all be upset if you asked them to pause the movie for you.

In addition to all this you have to be quiet. I can't talk to my wife about the movie as it's happening, and I can't laugh when I find things funny unless the filmaker intended them to be so (which is why I didn't watch An Inconvenient Truth in the theater). I got caught a couple times during Babel and got the evil eye from my wife. And if I miss something I can't rewind the movie to understand it. I just have to make up the storyline as I go.

When I compare this to watching a movie at home I conclude I must be crazy. At home it's free, comfortable, uncrowded. I can pause when I want, and even stop it for a few hours to be continued later.

SXome would say that there are movies that the theater improves, by which they mean it is louder, brighter and more likely to induce nausea. To that I say, Bah! give me a movie at home with my wife over one in the theater any day of the week.

Sunday, January 28, 2007

On fear II

So I've been thinking about this fear thing lately. It seems from my knowledge of the Bible that the phrase "fear of God" is intended to convey more than I have ever fully accepted, but less, I think, that what I have occasionally heard from others.

I think that the authors of the Bible were serious in their admonishment to fear God. And in intimate encounter human beings were undeniably afraid of God. The first such example is the case of Adam and Eve. Post-sin, they were ashamed and afraid, and so they hid from God. Moses certainly felt the fear when he spoke to the burning bush. And Isaiah's account includes its share. The one thing that all of these accounts share is a sense of insufficiency, and a recpgnition of God's role in Creation and judgement.

Judgement--a word from which our culture recoils. How often in a modern church do you hear about the judgement of God...and yet in a cursory search from memory, it is mentioned more often in the Bible than the love or mercy of God. But wait you say--Judgement is the Old Testement paradigm...the New Testement is all about the love man. I haven't researched exhaustively, but I'd bet that Judgement is a more common theme, even in the new testement. It is an inescapable part of the character of God. Ask yourself...would you really rather believe in a God that is morally neutral, or one that holds each individual to account for his actions. Should God really put me and Hitler on the same moral plane. In a certain sense of course, yes. We are both sinful wayward creations. But in another sense no. If God id truly God then He will hold Hitler to account for each of his actions.

So what does judgement have to do with fear? I'm not sure. But I think that when we truly have a firm grasp on our relationship to God and truly understand his holiness and our sinfulness then we will recognize that we have no option save to throw ourselves at his feet begging for mercy. This is I believe the beginning of the fear of the Lord. It is a constuctive fear. I am at a certain level, terrified of fire...for good reason. This fear leads me to respect its potential and to take steps to keep it from killing me. The same goes for water, cars, sharp sticks, pit bulls and God.

But doesn't this fear stop once I become a Christian and the threat of hell recedes? Perhaps not. According to the New Testement we will be held to account for our actions as God's servants. Will we be prepared for Judgement? As Paul says, if we build a house of straw we will escape on Judgement day as one escaping from flames. And according to the book of Revelation there are to books, the book of life and eht book where all our deeds are recorded. So the fear of God that stems from this recognition refines us and spurs us to greater heights.

To be continued...maybe

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

On a new technique

I tried something new tonight. I edited "On fear" as I was discussing it with a group of friends on a laptop with wireless internet...It was an interesting experience. Needless to say I stole some ideas. I may try it again.

Sunday, January 21, 2007

On a Holiday

This post would have been more meaningful if I had posted it on Monday when I wrote it. But I'll post it now in an abbreviated form anyway.

I had Monday of work. It was great. MLK Day is a great holiday for teachers, serving much the same purpose as Labor day...allowing us to ease into a new semester with an early three-day-weekend. But MLK day is a mystifying Holiday. As far as national holidays go it is unique I think. Some national holidays are pre-nation--Christmas, New Year's Day, Easter--some recognize significant events--July 4th, Veteren's Day--and some recognize groups of people--Veteren's Day, Memorial Day, Labor Day. One even recognizes a pair of individuals--Presidents Day (Washington and Lincoln). But only one, as far as I know, recognizes one person--MLK Day.. What's so special about Martin Luther King Jr.? Sure he made a significant impact on our country, but does he really deserve recognition as the only person to get his own holiday. Is he really the person who made the greatest impact on American history?

It's just an odd occasion for a holiday.

On Fear

What does it mean to be afraid of God?

"Who then is the man that fears the Lord. He will instruct him in the way chosen for him. He will spend his days in prosperity and his descendents will inherit the land. The Lord confides in those who fear him; he makes his covenant known to them."

I have often passed over references to the fear of God with a glib reminder to myself that it only really means respect or love. But what does it really mean to be afraid of God? I was struck this morning as I read this passage in Psalms. I would like some input here. What does it really mean to be afraid of God. Are you afraid of Him? If so, what does that look like?

We are quick to say that it doesn't mean to be terrified of God, but there is something terrible about God...not in a bad sense, but people tremble before God--think of Isaiah, or of Moses. When people encounter God in the Bible true terror is often the result.

I have heard many stories about people who have had very real, emotional, spiritual encounters with God and find themselves terrified.

It seems like perhaps we have lost the healthy fear of the sovereign that was common to most people in history. We have so much control over our lives that we lose sight of our own fragility. As our culture has changed we have done our best to remove or ignore the mystery of God, We turn our backs on the power of God.

Friday, January 05, 2007

A Review: The Lost City

In 1958 Cuba was held in the tightening grip of Fulgencio Batista, erstwhile democrat, reinvented as stereotypical Latin American strongman. Idiomatically as he squeezed power tighter and tighter, more and more groups began to slip through his fingers. The most famous now, though not neccessarily then was that led by Fidel Castro and Ernesto "Che" Guevarra. There were others, however. In the post WWII world on the back doorstep of the United States each of these groups sought to appeal to their bigger neighbor by speaking of democracy and pluralism. Paradoxically most also used the anti-imperial language of the day to argue against Batitsta as a stooge of the United States, propped up to ensure stability in the Carribbean in the early days of the Cold War.

In the end, Castro and Guevarra marched into Havanna on January 9, 8 days after Batista fled the country. They quickly abandoned any democratic ideal in favor of the brutal imposition of communist ideals. Guevarra was a particularly idealistic revolutionary who uickly set about reforming the economic, political and social systems. This involved lots of killing, lots of forced labor and lots of Cubans fleeing to semi-voluntary exile in New York and Miami. He was a classic example of a person who believed that the ends justify the means. He took this philosophy to its fullest extent, using the worst forms of injustice in pursuit of paridise for the people he genuinely loved.

Most literary and cinematic treatments of this period of Cuban history take one of two tracks. Either they portray Fidel and Che as idealistic revolutionaries bringing joy to the people, or they portray them as evil power grabbing monsters looking for a country to rule so they could confront the United States. Che in particular is rarely portrayed realistically.

The Lost City succeeds in presenting this period realistically to a degree I have rarely if ever seen. Batista is shown as the nasty tyrant he was, Fidel is shown as the would be tyrant he was, Che is shown as the amoral idealist he was, and the manifest failings of the communist revolution to shape a functioning society are at least alluded to.

It is the story of a nightclub owner Fico Fellove, played well by Andy Garcia, who is trying to hold together his splintering family and business through the trials of the time. One brother goes off to join Fidel in the mountains, another leads a band of would be liberators on a suicide mission to assassinate Batista in his palace. As Fidel begins to consolidate control and pressure mounts his club is shut down, his uncle killed for his tobacco plantation, his friends killed by his brother. Eventually he flees to the US to start over.

The movie is fascinating as a picture of the times, refusing to shed favorable light on any of the players, chosing instead to show it as the very difficult and trying time that it was. It is also an excellent portrait of an individual trying to make sense of the insanity of the world around us. Fico is forced out of his comfortable existence and forced to see and interact with the reality around him. It is a little slow at times, but there's a nice romantic twist and Bill Murray is funny as Fico's disillusioned friend. It is in English, which can be a bit disconcerting, but overall it is very well done.

Monday, January 01, 2007

On suffering

So it has been noted by finer minds than mine that most quality literature and in fact art deals with what most people would consider negative emotions--Fear, anger, betrayal, sadness, loss--and very little deals with things that we would actually want for ourselves--happiness, love... It has been noted that perhaps the downer side of art is more popular because it is truer to life--we do suffer, so we want to read about others doing so. This is I think at least in part valid.

But I have come across an interesting fact that may shed some light on why the darker side of life appeals more to us and why sad stories seem to move us more than happy ones.

"Most neuroscientists now recognize six basic emotions: anger, disgust, fear, joy, sadness and suprise [and a small number of] higher emotions such as embarrassment, shame, and sympathy."

Reading this list, one thing strikes me--we are hardwired to experience suffering. Perhaps this explains why even when we don't suffer we feel the compulsion to find suffering in our lives. It explains Western guilt and teenage angst. I suppose we developed this system of emotions to deal with life as it was lived by most of our ancestors. So the next time you're feeling down in the dumps, take comfort in the fact that you are feeling the suffering of thousands of generations of emotional development.

Wednesday, December 27, 2006

on a comment

Juanis Chanis said...
i guess the question is...why is it excuseable just because it's a biological process? After all, the end result is the same, and shouldn't that be the basis for our criminal justice system? If it's happened once, it could happen again, after all. And just because we can observe the biological processes doesn't mean that it wasn't the perpetrators' fault...

At issue is the question: can we hold someone responsible for, an event over which they had no control?

This question is at the heart of Christianity. Sin, we are told, entered the world through one man. Through his action we are all dead to sin. And many people are never given the chance to repent of their sins or turn to Christ, and yet ane damned.

But we don't like that idea. In, "not guilty by reason of insanity" is a valid plea in a court of law.

Besides all this, what should we do when we can figure out that someone has a biological predilection to murder before they actually murder someone? Should we take preventative measures & lock them up?

Tuesday, December 26, 2006

On prayer

"What can I tell thee thoudost not already know? What can I ask of thee thou wilt not give unasked if that's thy will? Yet I must ask thee even so."

Did you hear me as I called upon your name? Or do you hear and mark me now, sweet king? I have to hope that hope or else my heart will crack.

On Free Will

Modern science ha: of late delved into the study of the brain. Despite our seeming wealth of knowledge concerning the organ that forms the center of our consciousness, until recently we had relatively little knowledge about the biological processes involved in our thoughts and actions. It is now conceivable that we can figure out the biological causes of psychopathic behavior for example. We can determine Biologically why a person turns into a serial killer. What effect will this hare on the criminal justice system?

More and more, science is leading us down the road towards biological determinism. We have long accepted this sort of argument in the case of animals we have long accepted such thinking. Instinct weare told governs the actions of animals. And survival of the fittest is the rule. Animals are competing for resources and act without free will.

But humans are supposed to be different. A relatively large part of the history of philosophy is devoted to studying free will, At the most we have been willing to accept divine determinism. Very few philosophers have been willing to ever entertain the idea of biological determinism. As human beings we want to think of ourselves as somehow different, and virtually every religious tradition, including Christianity include in their origin story something that sets human beings apart from the rest of creation. In the case of Christianity , we are created in the image of God.

So the idea of biological determinism is a very difficult one to live by. In Fact I would argue that it is impossible to exist and function on a daily basis as human being and believe that everything you do is predetermined by biological processes. Yet we accept this as fact on a practical level every day. Much of modern medicineis based on this view of our relationship with our brain.And we allow these views into the courtroom to explain criminal behavior. After all we wouldn't want to hold Someone responsible for killing another if they did it because there was a tumor growing in their brain.

So my question is this - as we continue to learn more and more about the brain and its functioning , how do we maintain a sense of personal responsibility? for, without the understanding that each individual is responsible for his or her own actions the social order will collapse.

This is a problem that is only going to grow starker as we discover more about the working of the brain. Pressure will grow to let criminals go for stranger and stranger reasons. We are already told often enough that we are not really responsible for bad decisions we make. We Must find a way to combine our new understanding of Biological processes with the knowledge we cannot deny, that we act and make decisions every day and that we can be held responsible for those actions.

Monday, December 25, 2006

An existential dilemna

"Am I daft, or is it true there's no such thing as hours past and other hours still to pass, but all of them instead are all at once and never gone?" Godric

What is time?

This is a question I have often pondered in hours of philosophical gambol. I have talked and thought about it quite a bit over the course of my life. It is always fascinating and always unproductive.

So what is it? The units of measure we use to judge time are artificial constructs that we have constructed to give order to our lives. But what do they signify really. They identify periods, cycles. They also help us to classify changes that we see around us.

So time is really about change. But what really changes? This is a question that human beings have asked since the dawn of thought. The idea of reincarnation is based on the perception that nothing really changes, that ultimate reality is static.

As Christians, we claim that ultimate reality is in some sense static. One of the characteristics of God is that he is immutable. And a very popular description of God is that he is outside of time.

Even in physical reality there is a case to made for the ultimate changelessness of reality. Nature is about cycles: daily, monthly annual, biannual. Matter moves from one state to another, but it cannot be created or destroyed (well sort of).

So what is time? We live in it, our lives are defined by it. But is it real

A Nativity Reading

And my choice for the best nativity reading of all time. Of the best summary and explanation of the incarnation:

John 1:1-18

In it are summarized the purpose, method, scope, and outcome of the incarnation of Christ. I think that we should read this every Christmas to remember what we are celebrating. I myself read it when I woke up this morning as a certain little girl ate cereal and everyone else in the house slept.

Friday, December 22, 2006

On a song

I heard this song on the radio te other day. I enjoyed it. Something about it seems true to Christmas.

There are a few things I like:
First it doesn't stop with the birth of Christ. It encompasses Christ's time on Earth. To me the Christmas story is not just about a birth, but about the incarnation, death and resurrection or Christ. I like the nativity reading for Christmas day in the Anglican prayer book: John 1:1-18.

Second, I like the emphasis on the fact that Jesus associated with less than holy people. I think we often ignore that even though it is often proclaimed. Certainly the actions of the church today don't reflect the interests of Jesus in this regard.

Third, I like the line " Why in all this hatred do you fill me up with love?" This is a feeling I have often struggled with (not to equate myself with Christ).

One thing troubles me:
The line "the blood of all the children all around." I don't understand this and I have the unsettling feeling that it is a veiled attack on Christianity.

That said, I like the song. Perhaps it is Mr. Matthews voice. I have long thought that his voice is his primary attraction, though most tend to gravitate to his guitar playing. So here it is.

"A Christmas song"
Dave Matthews

She was his girl; he was her boyfriend
She'd be his wife and make him her husband
A surprise on the way, any day, any day
One healthy little giggling dribbling baby boy
The wise men came, three made their way
To shower him with love
While he lay in the hay
Shower him with love love love
Love love love
Love love was all around

Not very much of his childhood was known
Kept his mother Mary worried
Always out on his own
He met another Mary who for a reasonable fee,
less than reputable was known to be.

His heart full of love love love
Love love love
Love love was all around

When Jesus Christ was nailed to his tree
Said "oh, Daddy-o, I can see how it all soon will be
I came to shed a little light on this darkening scene
Instead I fear I've spilled the blood of my children all around"

The blood of my children all around
The blood of my children's all around

So I'm told, so the story goes
The people he knew were
Less than golden hearted
Gamblers and Robbers
Drinkers and Jokers, all soul searchers
Like you and me
Like you and me

Rumors insisted he soon would be
For his deviations
Taken into custody
By the authorities less informed than he.
Drinkers and Jokers all soul searchers
Searching for love love love
Love love love
Love love was all around

Preparations were made
For his celebration day
He said "eat this bread and think of it as me
Drink this wine and dream it will be
The blood of our children all around
The blood of our children's all around
The blood of our children all around

Father up above, why in all this hatred do you fill
Me up with love, love, love
Love love love
Love love was all around
Father up above, why in all this hatred do you fill
Me up with love, fill me love love love
Love love love
all you need is love
you can't buy me love
Love love love
Love love
And the blood of our children's all around

Monday, December 18, 2006

A review

Normally when I sit down to watch an Adam Sandler movie I expect to be entertained by mildly offensive humor and offended by mildly humerous entertainment. So I expected much of the same when I sat down with my wife to watch "Click", his latest effort. I was suprised though. It wasn't really that funny. There were to be sure a few funny parts fueled cheifly by Sandlers penchant for irrational exuberance. Yet strangly the oxymoron that is serious Adam Sandler turned out to be not that bad.

The movie is about an architect who is struggling with modern life. He is stretched thin by the demands on his time--primarily family and work. As many do he tends to see large parts of his life as obligatory sideshows of little interest--dinner with his parents, traffic, showering, even work. He is stretching for a promotion, and stretching his relationship with his family in the process.

Into this steps a man who offers him a universal remote of suprising power. He is now able to fast-forward through things, pause life, and go back to watch his memories. It is the first of these that he makes the most use of. He begins to fast-forward through life's little nusiances. But like a born alcoholic he quickly begins to move through bigger and bigger sections of life. An argument with his wife, an evening with boring dinner guests, a long night of work. Then in a fit of frustration at the failure to achieve a long hoped for promotion. He wakes up a year later; his body having moved through on autopilot while his mind skipped over. His marriage is falling apart, and he doesn't remember anything that has happened. He is understandable scared and resolves to use the remote less.

At this point the remote begins to take on a life of its own, fastforwarding through parts of his life automatically. The man who gave him the remote explains that the remote memorizes patterns and automatically anticipates his desires based on past actions. What follows is a miserable decline in which years go by at a time until he is an old dying man isolated from those around him by his years on autopilot.

So he gets what he always wanted, moving through the dull bits of life from high point to high point skipping the rest and dies a dispirited old man.

This movie is fascinating as a commentary on a certain part of modern life. Many of us tend to focus on making it through. If I can make it through to Christmas break then everything will get better. If I can get just get into medical school then life will be better. When I make it through medical school then I will have arrived. Like the never ending song we are always approaching the end in life, but never arriving. As human being we have been endowed with a sense of purpose. I am here for a reason. We assume that this nagging sense of purpose plagues us because we are meant to accomplish something. We carry an unresolved contradiction;we want to accomplish, yet are rarely satisfied by accomplishment. And so we push forward always focusing our eyes on a goal, near or far. When it is met or deemed impossible we pick a new goal on which to fasten our hopes.

The point of the movies is that our purpose is met, not in the end, but in the means. When we lose sight of this as our young hero did, we end up unsatisfied as our old hero did. There is a valuable lesson here for many in our society, but as Christians we can do better. We do have a purpose.

What is the cheif end of man?
To glorify God and enjoy him forever.

We have a sense of purpose because we have a purpose. We were created by God to glorify and enjoy him. And we tend to be unsatisfied because we latch onto the wrong goals. As Paul said--press on towards the goal as a runner in a race. This movie reminds me that I am to continually keep this in mind--not because it says so, but because of the twisted way inwhich my mind works.

Note: I include this last bit, not because its not obvious, I know it is. But because I personally am prone to forget it.

Note: The movie left several possibilities unexplored. I personally couldn't imagine using the fast-forward button, but boy would I be tempted by the pause button. Think of what I could get done if the world was on pause for a few hours. It would be great. I couls have a 26 hour day. Also I would have used the review function a bit more. I am fond of memories.

Saturday, December 16, 2006

A tribute




This picture makes me think of my brother--for reasons beyond the the obvious. Or perhaps I should say this picture represents how I see my brother and the things I like about him.

His intensity, his seriousness, his thoughtfulness, his devotion...they all come through in this picture. He is, despite his frustrating stubborness and occasional self-righteousness, a man of prayer and of God, and I love him.

I also like the fact that it is black and white, because more than perhaps any person I know this is how my brother sees the world. Right is right and wrong is wrong, intellectually, spiritually, personally. I appreciate this about him, because he helps remind me, that there is truth and there is falsehood and that they can be recognized.

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Of an interesting experience

Last Sunday I went to Sunday School (First time in a few years). It was an interesting experience. I went to a fairly conservative (theologically) church where my parents were married with my aunt and uncle in Ann Arbor. The class was about science and Christianity and taught by a professor at the University of Michigan.

I have been to many churches over the years, and most of them have dealt with the question of science in the same way: the earth was created in six days a few thousand years ago no matter what evidence science presents. In fact I held this view for a long time.

But for many years this issue has troubled me. In fact it wa a (relatively minor) factor in my exodus from Christianity. The weight of scientific evidence comes down on the side of evolution (there are of course difficulties, but overall the evidence makes a young earth view seem silly) and so I was left by the dichotomy presented in the church to either abandon the infallibility of the Word of God, or to embrace the view that God deliberately deceived us (in terms of what we can see) as to the age of the earth. This was an untenable position for me.

Eventually as I began to return to the church I realized that God often speaks in parables and allegory. The Bible besides being the Wor of God is a literary work. And so I came gradually to see the first few chapters of Genesis as an allegory or fable or some such literary device to help us understand God's relationship with the world and with man (that doesn't mean I understand fully what it means).

So it was interesting to me to be in a class of relatively conservative (theologically) Christians and hear my own view espoused as the general consensus and as the view of the instructor. As I left I couldn't help thinking, "Only in Ann Arbor..."

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

On Dostoevsky

Of all the Russian authors I've read, I think Dostoevsky is my favorite. I read Crime and Punishment a few years back, and I've been reading the Brothers Karamazov recently. His stories center on the issue of guilt. Both stories are about murder. In C and P the main character (Rashkalnikov?) kills and old woman and robs her to regain a pawned watch. This happens relatively early in the story and as the novel unfolds he is eaten away by his guilt until he confesses to the murder at the climax. BK is more of a mystery. Fyodor is killed and robbed, and all of the evidence points to his son Dimitri. As Dostoevsky presents the case, there is no conclusion we can draw other than that Dimitri has killed him despite his protestations (I'm not done yet, the trial is about to start).

These two characters are worthy of disgust, and are presented in the most unfavorable light. And yet it is impossible for me to do anything but sympathize with them and pity them. This is masterful storytelling at its best. I'm still trying to figure out how he does it. Somehow he manages to link these characters to me by their humanity, to open a window into what is universal in the human condition (guilt) and to convince me without saying it that I am them but for a matter of degree (don't worry Dad, its a pretty big degree).

Tolstoy on the other hand fails in this very exercise by my estimation. In Anna Karinina for instance, though I am told by Oprah that I should pity Anna, I can't. Instead I identify with Levin. Though I did enjoy the book.

Friday, December 08, 2006

Of planes

Tomorrow I leave for Michigan. Why is it hard to sleep on the eve of a voyage?

Here's the thing about having a blog: I feel like I have to post on something approaching a regular basis. This week has been kind of a down week. Sometimes I just get in a funk where my mind kind of goes numb. So I haven't had a lot of great thoughts this week. So I apologize for wasting the time you have spent checking my blog to see if I've posted anything new. (How's that for narcissism?)

Sunday, December 03, 2006

Of Blood and oil 2

The discussion surrounding the blood diamond thing got me thinking about a couple of things.

1. Do we have a responsibility as Christians to use less oil? This is a pretty divisive question. I tend to shy away from moral imperatives. So I think broadly, no. But on a personal level I think it is an issue we need to think about in light of our faith. We are the stewards both of our own resources and of the earth's resources. On both counts reducing oil use makes sense.

Using less oil saves money and allows us to put it towards more productive uses. Not only do I save money on gas by riding my bike or carpooling with my wife, but I also save money on the second car I don't have.

Using less oil also conserves more oil. No matter how much oil there is inside the earth there is a finite amount. There won't be any more--but maybe Christ will return (P.J. O'Rourke disagrees with me--he points to the example of whale oil. In the late nineteenh century we were running out of oil to power our lamps, but we still have whales and energy. So presumably when the price is right we will figure out an alternative.) There is also the issue of global warming, which I personally don't put much stock in (twenty years ago the scary prospect was global cooling. The same people fretting now about the whole earth being turned into a tropical paridise were then fretting about the whole earth turning into an Eskimo village.) ( The earth was significantly hotter than even the most extreme predictions at many points in its history and somehow species survived.) But burning that much of anything can't be good for us or for the envionment.

That said I think that using less oil is a good thing. I also think that the argument about being a good steward of my own resources is more important than the other.

2. Who decided that diamonds cause wars? Africa is the most war-torn area on the planet, and most of those wars aren't even in areas where diamonds are. Look at Chad, the Sudan, Somolia, these places don't even produce diamonds. The ones war that were ostensibly caused by diamonds were about a whole host of issues. Most diamond miners outside the major companies are self-employed diggers who dig for themselves not to fund a war. And DeBeers is a major force behind the anti-blood diamond movement (speaking of conflicts of interest). I just haven't seen any evidence that diamonds in any real way actually cause wars. It seems to me like what I said it was--western guilt at work.